Allegedly with Ellison Barber - Season 1

1. Gabby Petito: New Revelations

Aired: 4/29/2026

Emmy-winning journalist Ellison Barber revisits one of the most publicized true-crime cases of the decade. While the tragic story of Gabby Petito's disappearance and death during her 2021 cross-country road trip became a global obsession, Barber shifts the focus from familiar headlines to newly surfaced evidence.

2. Penthouse Predators: The Alexander Brothers

Aired: 5/6/2026

Ellison Barber unpacks the recent high-profile investigation regarding real estate brokers the Alexander brothers.

3. Sam Bateman: Polygamist Prophet

Aired: 5/13/2026

A conversation between Ellison Barber and cult psychology expert Christine Marie from Trust Me: The False Prophet.

4. Hell on Wheels : The Case of Mackenzie Shirilla

Aired: 5/20/2026

5. Episode 5

Aired: 5/27/2026

6. Episode 6

Aired: 6/3/2026