Aired: 11/13/2018
In Clintonville, OH, the murder of Christie Mulllins, a young 14-year-old girl in the year 1975, remains unsolved. Forty years after her death, a young woman comes forward, claiming her uncle to be the murderer.
Aired: 11/20/2018
After Charlie Kinkel goes missing in a Nevada mining town, his wife, Trayce, tries to investigate, but is shunned by locals. After a body is discovered, detectives discover Kinkel's murder was a tragic case of misplaced suspicion.
Aired: 11/27/2018
In Goliad, TX, Patricia Mills is killed in a house fire that her sister deems to be suspicious. It will take 10 years to break the silence surrounding this case, but Mills' killer is eventually brought to justice.
Aired: 12/4/2018
Donna Fontaine and her boyfriend, Fred Palahniuk, are found shot dead in a burning building in remote Kendrick, ID. A conspiracy of silence protects the killer until his lovers crack and confess the damning evidence needed to convict him.
Aired: 12/11/2018
Trudy Darby, a 42-year-old woman, is mysteriously murdered in the town of Mack's Creek, MO, after which, two more women disappear. The incidents shock the small community until a surprising call reveals that the killers are close at hand.
Aired: 12/18/2018
Sherry Leighty disappears from Altoona, PA, leaving her three small children behind. After a 13-year search, her sister discovers the rumor Leighty skipped town with a new boyfriend is a lie and people close to her have been harboring a dark secret.
